Introduction to the Comparative Study

This book was in my collection for quite some time. When I

acquired it, I planned to take notes and write a comparative

essay titled "A Study of Ebba Koch and Late P. N. Oak’s

Interpretations." However, due to various reasons, the project

was delayed. Now, I wish to continue the writing, present key

ideas in Marathi, and gauge readers’ reactions.

Late P. N. Oak’s views on the Taj Mahal have permeated

the public mind over the years. We have already introduced his

biographical aspects in earlier discussions about his book

"Netaji’s Encounters." Now, we analyze Ebba Koch’s work,

juxtaposing their interpretations in a balanced manner. As

Oak’s nephew, I might naturally emphasize his arguments more,

but I strive for objectivity.

Some of P. N. Oak’s core assertions include:

 1 Structure of the pinnacle and its symbolic elements

 2 Lotus petals forming an ‘Om’ shape

 3 Findings based on Carbon-14 dating

Before delving into these aspects, let’s review the book’s

general details. This 288-page publication, featuring 377

selected photographs and illustrations, was authored by Ebba

Koch, an Austrian scholar, who spent 10 years (1995-2005)

meticulously studying the Taj Mahal. She was a consultant to

the Archaeological Survey of India and also a Visiting Fellow at

Harvard’s Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture.2024 EBook 214 The Comparative Study of Tah Mahal 9 New Light on Taj. 12 May 2025

3

Her approach is not outright dismissive but rather

diplomatic in its arguments. In one instance, she amusingly

describes India’s contrasting modernity, noting that while

foreign tourists withdraw money from an ATM, they must

maneuver through cattle wandering nearby!

My copy of this book was published by Thames & Hudson

(2006) and is available on Amazon for £24.95.

A Comparative Review of

Ebba Koch and Late P. N. Oak

Introduction to the Comparative Study

This book was in my collection for quite some time. When I acquired it, I planned to take notes and write a comparative essay titled "A Study of Ebba Koch and Late P. N. Oak’s Interpretations." However, due to various reasons, the project was delayed. Now, I wish to continue the writing, present key ideas in Marathi, and gauge readers’ reactions.

Late P. N. Oak’s views on the Taj Mahal have permeated the public mind over the years. We have already introduced his biographical aspects in earlier discussions about his book "Netaji’s Encounters." Now, we analyze Ebba Koch’s work, juxtaposing their interpretations in a balanced manner. As Oak’s nephew, I might naturally emphasize his arguments more, but I strive for objectivity.

Some of P. N. Oak’s core assertions include:

v 1 Structure of the pinnacle and its symbolic elements 

v 2 Lotus petals forming an ‘Om’ shape 

v 3 Findings based on Carbon-14 dating